[Cwat]

I play in 10 keeper dynasty league. While I have CJ and Rice as my RB's, I have nothing else. My current WR's are Marshall, White, Housh, Gaffney, Manningham, Josh Morgan and Owens. As you can see I have Marshall, White and (you pick my 3/4th WR).

I have a trade offered to me for Marshall. In return I get Boldin and Mcfadden or Felix Jones. This is a PPR league. The only reason I would do this is to try and get depth at RB. I pick 10th in the draft, deep keeper, so the top rookie RB's will be gone when I pick.

Would you make this trade? Would you take Felix or McFadden?

[xDJCMx]

Methinks you are a little low on Marshall and White if they are "nothing else". I would hang on to Marshall. I'd stay clear of McFadden altogether and I don't see how Felix is possibly going to stay healthy. Boldin won't give you nearly as many years as Marshall will.

[steviep]

Agreed. I've seen ranks where Marshall is in the top 5. You should check out Andy's discussion on WRs. He has him ranked as #2 overall WR. White would fall in the top 10... not a bad team if you ask me. I guess the only question is who you are allowed to start week-to-week. A QB?, how many RBs? and how many WRs? In my league I can start up to 4 WRs, but a max of 2 RBs... so obviously WRs are important to me. But you might not be able to start that many so then if you trade away a WR, you need to make sure you get your value back. And it's no where in the vicinity of McFadden or Jones... Not even close. You need to think solid #2 RB, not #3 RB. Good luck.

[oneknut]

Marshall will be better than Boldin and McFadden is not even the starter yet on a bad Raiders team. At number 10 in the draft you could probably get an Ahmad Bradshaw, or another quality RB who shares that will out perform McFadden. Marshall for Boldin favors the other guy way to much.